Skip to main content

Sample Reviews

See the Transformation

Before-and-after examples showing how to transform generic drafts into compelling essays that stand out to admissions committees.

Example transformationsCommon mistakes illustratedExpert-level rewrites

College Admissions

Undergraduate Essay Examples

Common App and supplemental essays that helped students gain admission to Ivy League and top universities.

Example 1

The Failed Business Club

Prompt: Common App: Share an essay on any topic of your choice

BeforeOriginal Draft

When I was fifteen, my family moved to a smaller apartment across town. At first, I was upset. I had to leave my friends, switch schools, and share a room with my younger brother who talks in his sleep. It felt like my whole life got smaller. But over time, I started to notice things I hadn't before. I began walking to school instead of taking the bus. I passed by a mechanic's shop every morning and eventually started talking to the owner, Mr. Patel. One day he let me help change a tire... [Essay continues with generic "work hard" and "be patient" lessons learned from the mentor]

Issues Identified:

×Predictable 'moving taught me patience' narrative
×Generic mentor figure with fortune-cookie wisdom
×Could be written by thousands of other students
×Tells instead of shows—no specific, visual moments
AfterFinal Version

The first time I failed, it was spectacular. I had convinced my high school to let me start a small business club. I printed flyers, built a website, and got twenty people to show up to our first meeting. The next week, only three came back. By month two, it was just me and a box of untouched flyers. I remember sitting alone in the classroom one afternoon, staring at the whiteboard where I had written "Innovation Starts Here!" in bold blue marker. I felt embarrassed—like I had promised the world something I couldn't deliver. So I kept showing up. Every Wednesday at 3:15. I read business case studies, emailed local founders, and tried to learn why people start things that often fail. That empty room became a one-person incubator—not for a company, but for a mindset. One email led to a coffee meeting. One coffee meeting led to an interview. Soon I had collected 30 stories from entrepreneurs who had failed at least once before finding their path. I compiled them into a blog called "Side Street Stories" and shared it with my school's business teacher, who started using it in her curriculum. I learned that failure is not a wall; it's a mirror. It shows you who you really are when the audience leaves. And sometimes, the audience you're performing for isn't out there—it's you.

What Makes It Strong:

Opens with a memorable, specific hook
Concrete details ('Wednesday at 3:15', 'bold blue marker')
Original insight: 'failure is not a wall; it's a mirror'
Tangible creation: 30 profiles, blog used in curriculum
Example 2

The Sports Injury Pivot

Prompt: Common App: Discuss an accomplishment or realization

BeforeOriginal Draft

Soccer has always been my life. From the age of six, I spent every weekend on the field, practicing drills and playing in tournaments. When I tore my ACL during junior year playoffs, I thought my world was ending. The recovery was brutal. Six months of physical therapy, missing the entire season, watching my teammates from the sidelines. But through this challenge, I learned the true meaning of perseverance... [Essay continues with standard injury recovery narrative]

Issues Identified:

×Follows the exact formula: injury → recovery → perseverance
×Could be written by any athlete who got injured
×No unique insight or unexpected direction
×Generic 'I learned perseverance' conclusion
AfterFinal Version

I watched from the bench as my replacement missed the same pass I would have made. Then I did something that surprised me: I pulled out a notebook and started tracking patterns. Not plays or scores—patterns. How often did our midfielders drift right? When did our goalie's reaction time slow? What triggered our captain's visible frustration? What started as a way to stay connected to the team became an obsession with data. I built spreadsheets tracking 47 different variables across 12 games. My coach thought I was coping. I was discovering. By season's end, I had identified that our win rate improved 34% when we substituted fresh legs after the 60th minute—a pattern invisible to everyone watching, but clear in the numbers. The team that once saw me as an injured player started calling me "the analyst." My torn ACL ended my playing career. It started my intellectual one.

What Makes It Strong:

Unexpected pivot from injury to intellectual curiosity
Specific data and numbers show real engagement
Creates something tangible (spreadsheets, analysis)
Memorable ending that reframes the narrative
Example 3

Community Service Reframe

Prompt: Common App: Reflect on something that someone has done for you

BeforeOriginal Draft

Every Saturday for two years, I volunteered at the downtown homeless shelter. Serving meals and talking with residents opened my eyes to the struggles of those less fortunate than myself. One man named James taught me that everyone has a story. He was once a successful accountant before addiction took everything. His story taught me not to judge people by their circumstances... [Essay continues with lessons learned about gratitude and giving back]

Issues Identified:

×Centers the writer as enlightened helper
×Patronizing framing of 'the less fortunate'
×Uses a homeless person's trauma as character development
×Generic moral about not judging others
AfterFinal Version

The shelter's intake form was seven pages long. I watched a man spend forty minutes filling it out, only to be told he was missing his state ID—a document he couldn't get without a permanent address he didn't have. This wasn't a story about compassion. It was a systems problem. I started mapping the documentation requirements across every service in our county: food assistance, housing vouchers, medical care, job training. The diagram looked like a maze designed by someone who had never been lost. My AP Government teacher let me present my findings to the county commissioner's office. The policy analyst there told me something I'll never forget: "Most people who try to help the homeless focus on meals. You focused on the maze." I don't know if my research changed anything. But I learned that empathy without systems thinking is just sentiment. The maze won't unravel itself because we feel bad about it.

What Makes It Strong:

Identifies systemic issue, not just personal story
Creates tangible work (documentation mapping)
Sophisticated insight about empathy vs. systems
Shows intellectual engagement, not just service hours

Graduate Admissions

MBA, Law & Med School Examples

Essays that helped professionals gain admission to Harvard Business School, Yale Law, UCSF Medicine, and other top programs.

Business School

MBA Goals Essay

Prompt: HBS: What more would you like us to know? (900 words)

BeforeOriginal Draft

I have always been passionate about business and leadership. Growing up watching my father run his small company taught me the value of hard work and entrepreneurship. After graduating from college, I joined a consulting firm where I have spent the last three years advising Fortune 500 companies on strategy. This experience has confirmed my desire to pursue an MBA to advance my career to the next level... [Essay continues with generic career goals and why HBS]

Issues Identified:

×'Always been passionate' is a red flag opening
×Generic father-entrepreneur backstory
×Vague career progression with no specific impact
×'Advance my career' shows unclear goals
AfterFinal Version

The spreadsheet said the factory should close. My analysis was airtight—$3.2M annual savings, 18-month payback. But when I presented to the client's CEO, she asked one question I couldn't answer: "Have you met the 847 people who work there?" I hadn't. So I did. What I learned changed how I think about consulting. The plant's efficiency problems weren't structural—they were informational. Floor managers had identified solutions years ago that never reached leadership. The real problem was a 12-layer hierarchy that filtered out bad news. I proposed a different recommendation: flatten the reporting structure and implement a direct feedback system. Six months later, the factory's output increased 23%. It's still open. That project taught me the limits of analytical frameworks when separated from human context. It's why I'm pursuing an MBA focused on operations and organizational behavior—not to manage spreadsheets better, but to understand what the spreadsheets miss. At HBS, I want to study with Professor Edmondson on psychological safety in organizations. Her research on "teaming" describes exactly what I saw fail at that factory—and what I want to build in my career as a COO transforming legacy manufacturing companies.

What Makes It Strong:

Opens with specific, memorable moment
Quantified impact ($3.2M, 847 people, 23%)
Shows intellectual evolution, not just career progression
Specific professor and research interest
Law School

Law School Personal Statement

Prompt: Yale Law: 250-word personal statement

BeforeOriginal Draft

I want to attend law school because I believe in justice and want to make a difference. Growing up, I witnessed inequality in my community that inspired me to pursue a career where I could advocate for those without a voice. My undergraduate experience studying political science deepened my understanding of legal systems and their impact on society...

Issues Identified:

×'Believe in justice' is what every applicant says
×No specific experience or intellectual question
×Passive observation of inequality, no action taken
×Generic academic background description
AfterFinal Version

My grandmother's landlord raised her rent by 40% the month she was diagnosed with cancer. When I researched her options, I found that New York's rent stabilization laws had a loophole for "major capital improvements" that landlords exploited routinely. Her building's lobby renovation—marble floors she couldn't walk on—justified pricing her out. I spent that summer mapping MCI filings across 200 buildings in her neighborhood. The pattern was clear: improvements correlated with elderly tenant displacement, not building conditions. I submitted my findings to the city's housing court, where a judge cited them in a subsequent ruling limiting retroactive MCI increases. Law school isn't about "making a difference" in the abstract. It's about understanding how legal frameworks create the loopholes that harm people like my grandmother—and learning to close them.

What Makes It Strong:

Specific, personal story with real stakes
Concrete research and tangible outcome
Demonstrates legal reasoning already
Clear intellectual purpose for law school
Medical School

Medical School Personal Statement

Prompt: AMCAS: Why do you want to be a physician?

BeforeOriginal Draft

I have wanted to be a doctor since I was eight years old when my grandfather was hospitalized with a heart attack. Watching the physicians care for him with such compassion and expertise inspired me to pursue medicine. Throughout my undergraduate years, I have confirmed this passion through volunteering at the local hospital and shadowing physicians across multiple specialties...

Issues Identified:

×Childhood inspiration story is extremely common
×Passive 'watching' and 'volunteering' experiences
×No evidence of intellectual engagement with medicine
×'Confirmed my passion' without showing how
AfterFinal Version

The patient in Room 4 had been admitted three times in two months for diabetic ketoacidosis. I was just the scribe, documenting his history, but I noticed something: each admission came within a week of his insulin refill date. I mentioned this to his physician, who discovered that the patient's pharmacy was 11 miles away—impossible to reach without a car. His "non-compliance" was actually a transportation problem. We connected him with a pharmacy delivery service. He hasn't been readmitted in eight months. This experience crystallized why I want to practice medicine: the intersection of clinical reasoning and systems thinking. A diagnosis identifies what's wrong biologically. But treatment requires understanding the patient's entire context—their transportation, their work schedule, their insurance formulary. I've since led a quality improvement project analyzing readmission patterns among diabetic patients at our hospital. The data suggests that 34% of preventable readmissions involve medication access issues—a finding that's now informing our discharge planning protocols. I want to become a physician who treats diseases and the systems that prevent patients from managing them.

What Makes It Strong:

Shows clinical observation skills
Demonstrates systems-level thinking
Quantified impact and ongoing research
Clear vision for physician identity

Takeaways

What Separates Good from Great

01

Open with Specificity

'The first time I failed, it was spectacular' beats 'I have always been passionate about...'

02

Show, Don't Tell

'Wednesday at 3:15' is memorable. 'I learned perseverance' is forgettable.

03

Create Something Tangible

30 published profiles proves initiative. 'I learned patience' proves nothing.

04

Develop Original Insights

'Failure is a mirror' is memorable. 'Work hard and be patient' is generic.

05

Think in Systems

The strongest essays identify patterns and systemic issues, not just personal feelings.

06

Be Irreplaceable

The weak essay could be about anyone. The strong essay could only be about you.

Ready to Transform Your Essay?

Get the same expert feedback that helped these students get admitted. Our editors know what top schools are looking for.

3-5 day turnaroundSatisfaction guaranteedIvy League editors